How to choose an air purifier
Indoor Air Pollution Fact Checks
SANCTUARYAIR
purely for your health
Phone 03 8560 2111
Manufacturer of premium quality central air purifiers
Sanctuary Air SA-250 Series
Disclaimer Copyright © Sanctuary Air Victoria 2015
The effectiveness of an air-cleaning device in removing pollutants from an occupied space depends on three primary factors: 1) the filter's particle removal efficiency, 2) the air flow rate passing through the filter, usually expressed as cubic meters per hour; and 3) the air flow pattern, i.e. the path that the clean air follows after it leaves the filter.
The effectiveness of an air-cleaning device can also be affected by
1) whether the purifier can be operated economically 24/7, because re-contamination is continuous, as is your breathing. 2) The noise level should not prevent people from spending time in the purified zone, 3) whether pure air can be distributed to all frequently occupied spaces within the premises at the same time.
The following table explains some of Key Performance Indicators of three types of air-cleaning devices/systems using HEPA filters:
An air purifier competes against continuous re-contamination occurring within the space.
The effectiveness of an air-cleaning device is a measure of its ability to reduce airborne particle or gaseous pollutant concentrations in an occupied space. AHAM recommends an effectiveness of 80% as a meaningful indicator, which is consistent with Australian Standard AS 1668.2-2002 (Part 2, Ventilation design for indoor air contamination control). For example, a purifier with a coverage specification of 20 sq.meter, indicates that the device can achieve 80% effective reduction in steady particle concentrations in an indoor space of 20 sq.meter.
On the other hand, a filter's particle removal efficiency is usually expressed as a percentage of pollutants removed from the air that passes through it. For example, a filter may remove 99% of the particles from the air that passes through it (i.e., have 99% efficiency). However, if the airflow rate through the filter is only 15 cubic meters per hour (cmh) in a typical room of approximately 29 cubic meters (e.g., 4 x 3 x 2.4), the filter will be relatively ineffective at removing particles from the air (i.e., 10 times less effective than if the airflow rate were 150 cmh).
A filter rating of 99.97% efficiency DOES NOT translate directly to 99.97% effectiveness of a purifier.
NOTE [1]AIR FLOW RATE AND CLEAN AIR DELIVERY RATE (CADR)
CADR is a voluntary standard developed by the Association of Home Appliance Manufacturers (AHAM), and is recognized by the American National Standards Institute. The standard compares the effectiveness of a brand new portable air cleaners in a room size test chamber, by measuring the CADR for each of three types of particles in indoor air: dust, tobacco smoke, and pollen. For example, an air portable unit that has a CADR of 250 for tobacco smoke can reduce tobacco smoke particle levels to the same concentration as would be achieved by adding 250 cubic feet per minute, equivalent to 425 cubic meters per hour of clean air.
Because air flow resistance increases as the filter efficiency rating increases and or filter surface decreases, it is very challenging for a portable unit to achieve high CADR using a genuine HEPA filter of practical size without incurring high energy consumption and/or high noise levels.
As this is a voluntary American standard, some Australian and European models may not have a CADR rating.
The CADR testing does not apply to whole-house air-cleaning devices due to a different air flow pattern.
NOTE [2] AIR FLOW PATTERN
Due to the close proximity between inlet and outlet of a portable unit, a portion of purified air is re-drawn or short-circuited back to the unit before mixing sufficiently with the rest of air in the room. In effect, the purifier uses a portion of energy circulating pure air along the air path without purifying air further away.
On the other hand, ducted purification systems have a much more efficient air flow pattern:
NOTE [3]ENERGY EFFICIENCY
Purifiers installed in the return duct of ducted heating/cooling (HVAC) systems that rely upon the air mover within the existing HVAC system argueably consume no additional power when the HVAC system is operating. However, your HVAC, either be a reverse cycle conditioner or gas ducted heater, operates less than 15% of the time throughout a year. When cooling or heating is not required, it can be very expensive to use the air mover of your HVAC system to operate your air purifier continuously, because these air movers are design to move large volume of air for a short period of time and can consume 500 to 1500 watts. 24/7 air purification is very expensive for HVAC return-duct purifiers.
On the other hand, an independent ducted purification system will have a dedicated air mover that is specifically designed to operate continuously. A well designed independent ducted purification system can achieve the same power consumption of a typical portable unit for the reasons that:
An independent ducted purification system can operate 24/7 economically.
PERFORMANCE INDICATORS | TYPE OF AIR PURIFICATION SYSTEMS | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
Portable Units | In-duct purifier installed in the return duct of a HVAC system | Independent ducted air purification system | ||
Particle Removal Efficiency | Equivalent to efficiency of the HEPA filter of choice. Look for a genuine HEPA filter of sizable area. The larger the filter area is, the lower its air resistance and the greater its dust holding capacity. | |||
Air flow rate NOTE [1] | CADR is a measure of a portable air cleaner’s delivery of contaminant-free air, expressed in cubic feet per minute. It is essentially the air flow rate multiplied by filter efficiency. CADR is limited by the filter size and the noise level of a portable unit. | CADR rating does not apply to ducted whole-house purifiers due to a different airflow pattern. | ||
Air flow rate of an in-duct purifier depends on the air mover of existing HVAC. e.g. a R/C ducted system. | Air flow rate of an independent ducted purifier can be optimisedwithout restrictions of an existing HVAC. | |||
Air flow pattern NOTE [2] | Some Short-circuiting of the air path is unavoidable due to close proximity of air inlet and outlet. | Air is distributed more evenly via a multiple outlet ducted system. Positive air pressure can be created for priority zones. | ||
Space coverage | Space coverage is the floor area (assuming ceiling height of 2.4 m), in which a purifiercan achieve an 80% reduction in steady pollutant concentrations. | |||
Follow AHAM 2/3 rule: e.g. 120 sq.ft (11.15 sq.meters) requires a portable unit with smoke and tobacco CADR at least 80. | Under the guidance of AS 1668.2-2002, a typical dwelling of 150 sq. meters (1,615 sq. ft) will require a ducted system with an air flow rate about 750 cubic m/h or 210 L/sec to achieve 80% reduction. | |||
Energy efficiency NOTE [3] | Portable units typically consume 80-120 Watts at maximum air speed, depending on CADR and models. | It can be very expensive to run the air mover of an existing HVAC system 24/7, costing anything from $1,200 to $2,400 per year. | High quality independent ducted systems consume no more power than typical portable purifiers. 24/7 operation is economical. | |
Noise level | The noise threshold specified by WHO for undisturbed sleep is 30 dBA. It is important to check a unit's noise level at all speed settings. | The noise level is that of the existing HVAC system. | Noise can be isolated to an inaudible level. You can have undisturbed sleep with the full benefit of pure air. | |
Space efficiency | Requires floor space | Requires no floor space, not visible | ||
Filter life | For a given air flow or CADR, filter life increases exponentially as area increases. In general, larger filters save money in replacement over a given period. | |||
Filter accessibility | Filters of a portable unit are easily accessible and changeable by user | It is important to consider ease of access for filter change. Some ducted systems require entry to the loft or underfloor and may require a serviceman. A well designed system provides room-side access avoiding health and safety hazards associated with entering the loft or basement. | ||
Other performances | A portable unit serves a single room. It achieves the best result when the room is closed. | A in-duct purifier can improve the cleanliness of the existing HVAC network. | Independent ducted systems can utilise room-located heating or cooling devices distributing warm or cool air evenly to ducted zones. |
How to choose an air purifier
Indoor Air Pollution Fact Checks
Quality Australian Made Ducted Air Purifiers
SANCTUARYAIR
Purely for health
03 8560 2111
Sanctuary Air SA-250 Series